A Potential Framework for Thinking About an Overall Strategy for Psychiatric Freedom

Jim Gottstein

Last modified 11/16/04

 

The following is a draft of an outline I am putting together from various sources and through my own thinking.  I intend to expand this into something like a "White Paper." 

 

1.   Organizing Principles

1.1.        Freedom, Equality and Human Rights

1.2.        Psychiatry Has and Uses Abusive Power Driven by Fear and Absolution, Justified by Faulty Science, and Sustained by Lies

1.2.1.   No Biological Basis for mental illness

1.2.2.   “Medical Model” Psychiatric “Treatments” are extremely dangerous, destroy lives and ultimately ineffective for their primary purposes, to wit: protection and control.

1.3.        People are Entitled to the Truth

1.4.        People are Entitled to be Free of Coercive Treatment that is based on Lies.[1]

1.5.        People Are Entitled to Treatments of Their Own Choosing, based on Accurate Information.

2.   Goals[2]

2.1.                    Acknowledgement of Truth About Medical Model Treatments (Truly Informed decision making)

2.2.                    Recognition of emotional basis of psychiatric symptoms

2.3.                    Elimination of Coercive Treatment

2.4.                    Availability of Truly helpful Alternatives

3.   Roots of Psychiatric Power

3.1.        Society Has Abdicated to the Psychiatrists out of Fear

3.2.        The Mothers (and many of their “mentally ill” children) Have Been Seduced by Psychiatry’s Absolution from Responsibility.

3.3.        The Mothers Are Also Terrified of What Will Happen to their children.

4.   Psychiatry’s Strengths

4.1.                    Essentially Unlimited Financial Resources courtesy the Pharmaceuticals

4.2.                    Stature in Society

4.2.1.   Presumed experts. 

4.2.2.   Power to lock people up and force “treatment” on them merely through invocation of their status as experts.

4.3.                    Stranglehold on “The Story” in the Media.

4.4.                    Alliance with the Mothers (i.e., on the side of motherhood)

5.   Psychiatry’s Vulnerabilities

5.1.                    Morally Bankrupt

5.2.                    Intellectually Bankrupt

5.2.1.   The Lies

5.2.2.               Medical Model

5.2.3.               Mental Illness is a biologically based brain disease (defective brain).

5.2.4.               Mental Illness is incurable (i.e., can’t recover from it). 

5.2.5.               Dangerousness

5.2.6.               Effects of “Treatments”

5.2.7.               Toxic

5.2.8.               Addictive

5.2.9.               Prevents Recovery

5.2.10.           Causes Relapses

5.2.11.           Destroy Lives (lower expectations so much that relapse prevention is only goal).

5.2.12.           If those people weren’t crazy they’d know what we are forcing on them is best for them

5.3.                    Fiscally Bankrupting

5.3.1.   Virtually everybody sucked into the public system ends up permanently disabled and a drain on the public fisc.

5.4.                    Coercive Psychiatrists’ Cowardice

5.5.                    Psychiatry’s Arrogance

5.6.                    Psychiatry’s Greed

5.7.                    Excesses Have made it a virtual caricature of itself

5.7.1.   “Obsessive Shopping Disorder” treated with Paxil (or whatever it was).

6.   Chinks Are Appearing In Psychiatry’s Armor

6.1.                    Recent Revelations about the SSRIs[3]

6.2.                    Pharmaceutical Corruption of Government Processes

6.2.1.   Children dying from polypharmacy in Pennsylvania. 

6.2.2.   Pharmaceutical Companies Corrupting the procurement process.

6.3.                    Corruption in Medical Publishing

7.   Our Strengths

7.1.                    Grass Roots Support

7.1.1.   We actually have a lot of allies

7.1.2.               MindFreedom/Support Coalition International has over 100 organizations

7.1.3.               NARPA and its Membership

7.1.4.               ICSPP and its Membership

7.1.5.               All of the many C/S/X groups

7.1.6.               MDRI

7.1.7.               Many listserv groups

7.1.8.               ISPS and its members???

7.1.9.               Many more that I don't know about

7.2.                    Moral High Ground/Righteousness of Cause

8.   Our Weaknesses

8.1.                    Poor as Church mice

8.2.                    Confederation Type of Organization

9.   Existing and Potential Campaigns

9.1.                    United Nations

9.2.                    World Health Organization

9.3.                    Screening

9.4.                    MindFreedom Shield

9.5.                    MindFreedom Sanctuary

9.6.                    Expansion of ECT Globally

9.7.                    Congress

9.8.                     

9.9.                     

9.10.               The Emperor Is Naked

9.11.                

 

10.         Spheres of Action

10.1.               Media (TV/Radio/Newspapers/Magazines, Etc.)

10.1.1.                       Needs to be organized

10.1.2.                       Needs to be a constant effort

10.1.3.                       Need to develop relationships with members of media

10.1.4.                       Promote investigations of scandals

10.1.5.                       Get media to recognize there is another side to story and have list of people to talk to

10.1.6.                       Develop Speakers Bureau

10.1.7.           Peter Breggin

10.1.8.           David Cohen

10.1.9.           Bruce Levine

10.1.10.      Larry Simon

10.1.11.      Pat Deegan

10.1.12.      Bob Whitaker (Mad in America author)

10.1.13.      Dan Fisher

10.1.14.      Laurie Ahern

10.1.15.      David Oaks

10.1.16.      Tom Behrendt

10.1.17.      Bill Stewart

10.1.18.      Sue Rogers

10.1.19.      Ron Bassman

10.1.20.      Stefan P. Kruszewski, M.D.

10.1.21.      Mary Ellen Copeland

10.1.22.      Jim Gottstein

10.1.23.      Michael Perlin

10.1.24.      Bert Karon

10.1.25.      Pat Risser

10.1.26.      Celia Brown

10.1.27.      Darby Penny

10.1.28.      etc.

10.1.29.                  Strikes, Protests, Other actions to get attention

10.1.30.      MindFreedom's Sphere?

10.1.31.      MindFreedom Sanctuaries???

10.1.32.                  Other Efforts

10.2.               Legal

10.2.1.                       PsychRights' Sphere?

10.2.2.                       Expose the Lies (our experts and the power of the subpoena). 

10.2.3.           Attack prescribing authority under "informed consent" requirements.

10.2.4.           Prevent Court Ordered Forced Druggings  See, http://psychrights.org/calltoaction.htm

10.2.5.                       Prevent Other forms of Forced Drugging

10.2.6.                       Prevent Involuntary Commitments

10.2.7.                       (Seriously) Sue the Bastards

10.2.8.                       False Advertising with FTC (but does FDA action insulate?)

10.3.               Competition/Alternatives

10.3.1.                       ICSPP and/or ISPS Sphere?

10.3.2.                       Availability of Alternatives (Needs to be able to access the same public funding sources).

10.4.               Policy

10.4.1.                       Current System Creating Budget Crisis

10.4.2.           Everyone put on Welfare rolls and no one getting off.

10.5.               Politics[4]

10.5.1.                   NOTE: THERE ARE SEVERE RESTRICTIONS ON USING 501(c)(3) FUNDS FOR THIS!!

10.5.2.                       “Investigations.”

10.5.3.           FDA Corruption

10.5.4.           Pharmaceutical Corruption of procurement and prescribing

10.5.5.                       Elections

10.5.6.                       Legislation

11.         Needs

11.1.               Develop Plan

11.1.1.                       Clear Goals are Needed! 

11.1.2.                       Which Spheres to Address (all, but to varying degrees?)

11.1.3.                       What is Realistic/Prioritization/Mobilization (ramp up)

11.2.               $$$$$$$

11.3.               Organizing

11.3.1.                       Task Assignments and Overall Monitoring of Efforts/Progress

11.3.2.           Need Structure that organizes the disparate supporters

11.3.3.           Harness Volunteer Power

11.3.4.                       Pieces waiting to be put together?

11.3.5.           Public Education

11.3.6.           MindFreedom

11.3.7.           National Empowerment Center

11.3.8.           NARPA and its members

11.3.9.           ICSPP membership

11.3.10.      PsychRights

11.3.11.      Others?

11.3.12.      Competition/Alternatives

11.3.13.      ICSPP Membership

11.3.14.      Self-Help programs

11.3.15.      Ad hoc

11.3.16.      Others?

11.3.17.      Networking

11.3.18.      MindFreedom

11.3.19.      National Empowerment Center

11.3.20.      NARPA

11.3.21.      ICSPP Membership

11.3.22.      PsychRights

11.3.23.      Others?

11.3.24.      Legal

11.3.25.      PsychRights

11.3.26.      NARPA

11.3.27.      Protection & Advocacy Agencies/NAPAS

11.3.28.      Public Defenders

11.3.29.      Bazelon

11.3.30.      Private Bar

11.3.31.      Others?

11.3.32.      Expert Witnesses

11.3.33.      ICSPP Membership

11.3.34.      Ad hoc

11.3.35.      Others?

11.3.36.      Political[5]

11.3.37.      ICSPP Membership

11.3.38.      MindFreedom/SCI

11.3.39.      NARPA's membership

11.3.40.      Grass Roots

11.3.41.      Others?

11.3.42.      Policy

11.3.43.      NARPA and its members

11.3.44.      National Empowerment Center

11.3.45.      MindFreedom

11.3.46.      ICSPP membership

11.3.47.      PsychRights

11.3.48.      Others?

 



[1] Many people including myself would go quite a bit farther than this.  Unless of course one is literal, which makes this mean coercive treatment is virtually never or even never justified.

[2] As with all of this, these are just ideas to see if people are interested in taking about these issues.  The first one is from a conversation with David Oaks.  The next three are either explicit or implicit from past efforts.  The last one -- availability of alternatives -- seems to me to be essential to success because people will say, "OK, what would you do?"

[3] This really could just be the first stage of discrediting these medications as their patents are about to run out in favor of "new and improved" poisons, but even if that was the original idea, it seems to have now gone far beyond that. 

[4] Politics and Policy might be viewed as one category

[5] There are severe IRS limitations on political action for 501(c)(3)s so this should probably be done through non 501(c)(3) umbrellas.  The main issue is spending money.