Michigan
MI ST 330.2020
Chapter
330. Mental Health Code
Mental
Health Code
Chapter
10. Criminal Provisions
Transfer
of Prisoners
330.2001a. Definitions
Sec. 1001a. (1)
"Center for forensic psychiatry program" means that program
established by the center for forensic psychiatry to provide services related
to all of the following:
(a) Persons who are
alleged to be incompetent to stand trial.
(b) Persons who are
acquitted of criminal charges by reason of insanity.
(c) Persons who are
transferred to the center from places of detention or from other state
psychiatric hospitals.
(2) "Corrections
mental health program" means that program of the department of
corrections that is responsible for the provision of mental health
services to certain prisoners under this chapter.
(3) "Hearing
committee" means a committee appointed by the corrections mental health
program pursuant to section 1003c. [FN1]
(4) "Mental
health services" means the provision of mental health care in a protective
environment to prisoners with mental illness or mental retardation, including,
but not limited to, chemotherapy and individual and group therapies.
(5) "Mental
illness" means a substantial disorder of thought or mood that
significantly impairs judgment, behavior, capacity to recognize reality, or
ability to cope with the ordinary demands of life.
(6) "Mentally
retarded" means significantly subaverage general
intellectual functioning that originates during the developmental period and is
associated with impairment in adaptive behavior.
330.2001b. Definitions
Sec. 1001b. (1)
"Place of detention" means a detention facility operated by a
political subdivision of the state.
(2)
"Prisoner" means a person confined in a state correctional facility,
but does not include any of the following:
(a) A person confined
pursuant to an order of a juvenile division of the probate court or the family
division of circuit court.
(b) A person confined
in a place of detention.
(c) A person who is on
parole from a state correctional facility.
(3) "Protective
environment" means an environment that supports mental health services in
accordance with a prisoner's individual plan of services.
(4) "State
correctional facility" means a facility that houses prisoners and is
operated by the department of corrections, and also includes a youth
correctional facility operated by the department of corrections or a private
vendor under section 20g of 1953 PA 232, MCL 791.220g.
330.2002a. Mental
health services for prisoners
Sec. 1002a. (1) For a
person confined in a place of detention operated by a political subdivision of
the state and who requests mental health services, mental health services shall
be provided by the appropriate community mental health program pursuant to the
responsibilities described in section 206. [FN1]
(2) The department of
mental health shall promulgate rules pursuant to Act No. 306 of the Public Acts
of 1969, as amended, being sections 24.201 to 24.315 of the Michigan Compiled Laws, establishing a procedure for the
voluntary admission into a state mental health facility of a person confined in
a place of detention operated by a political subdivision of the state.
(3) The involuntary
admission into a state mental health facility of a person confined in a place
of detention operated by a political subdivision of the
state shall be governed by sections 423 to 444. [FN2]
330.2003. Establishment
and operation of corrections mental health program for prisoners; review of
structure and standards; qualifications of director
Sec. 1003. The
department of corrections shall establish and operate the corrections mental
health program to provide mental health services for prisoners who are mentally
retarded or mentally ill and need those services. The director of the
department of mental health shall review the program's structure, content,
quality standards, and implementation. The department of corrections may
contract with the department of mental health to operate the corrections mental
health program. The department of corrections shall not contract with any other
provider to operate the program. The director of the department of corrections
shall appoint the director of the corrections mental health program. The
director of the corrections mental health program shall be an individual with
an advanced degree in a mental health field and a minimum of 5 years'
experience in a mental health field.
330.2003a. Involuntary
admission of prisoners to corrections mental health program; procedures
Sec. 1003a. The following
procedures apply to involuntary admission to the corrections mental health
program:
(a) A person may file
with the officer in charge of a state correctional facility a written notice
alleging that a particular prisoner is mentally ill or mentally retarded and
requires treatment. Upon receipt of the written notice, the officer in charge
of the facility shall contact the corrections mental health program, which
shall initiate an evaluation by a mental health professional. If the officer in
charge of a state correctional facility receives a report from a mental health
professional that a prisoner may be mentally ill, the officer shall ensure that
the prisoner is examined by a psychiatrist as soon as administratively
possible. If the report from the mental health professional states that the
prisoner may be mentally retarded, the officer shall ensure that the prisoner
is examined by a psychologist as
soon as administratively possible. Unless the prisoner can be
examined within the facility where he or she is housed, the prisoner shall be
transferred to an appropriate facility for examination.
(b) Upon completion of
the examination described in subdivision (a), the psychiatrist or psychologist
shall execute a certificate of findings that specifies whether, in the
psychiatrist's or psychologist's opinion, the prisoner is mentally ill or
mentally retarded. If a finding of mental illness or mental retardation is
made, the psychiatrist or psychologist shall recommend suitable treatment
available within the corrections mental health program.
(c) Upon completion of
the examination described in subdivision (a), if the psychiatrist or
psychologist determines that the prisoner is mentally ill or mentally retarded
and is a present danger to himself or herself or to others, and if the prisoner
refuses treatment, the psychiatrist may order involuntary administration of
psychotropic medication pending a hearing pursuant to section 1003c. [FN1]
(d) Upon completion of
the certificate required under subdivision (b), the officer in charge of the
state correctional facility shall provide to the prisoner and the guardian of
the person, if applicable, a copy of the certificate, a copy of the
psychiatrist's or psychologist's report of the examination, and a notice of
hearing explaining hearing procedures and rights set forth in section 1003c.
The documents shall be provided at least 24 hours before the hearing.
(e) If the prisoner
agrees with the treatment recommended under subdivision (b), the prisoner may
execute a waiver of hearing and consent to treatment.
(f) If the prisoner
refuses the treatment recommended under subdivision (b), a hearing shall be
held pursuant to section 1003c.
(g) The prisoner shall
not be medicated for 24 hours before a hearing held under section 1003c.
(h) If, following a
hearing held pursuant to section 1003c, the hearing committee finds that the
prisoner is not mentally retarded or mentally ill, the prisoner shall be placed
according to normal procedures of the department of corrections. If the hearing
committee finds that the prisoner is mentally retarded or mentally ill and that
the proposed services are suitable to the prisoner's condition, the corrections
mental health program shall provide the mental health services designated by
the hearing committee. If the hearing committee finds that the prisoner is
mentally ill or mentally retarded but that the proposed services are not
suitable to the prisoner's condition, the corrections mental health program
shall provide services that are available within the corrections mental health
program that are suitable to the prisoner's condition as ordered by the hearing
committee.
330.2003b. Voluntary
admission of prisoners to corrections mental health program; procedures
Sec. 1003b. The
following procedures apply to voluntary admission to the corrections mental
health program:
(a) If a prisoner
desires to be voluntarily admitted to the corrections mental health program,
the officer in charge of the state correctional facility in which the prisoner
is housed shall transfer the prisoner, if necessary, to the appropriate
location designated by the corrections mental health program for an examination
by a psychiatrist or a psychologist, as applicable. If the examining
psychiatrist or psychologist certifies to the corrections mental health program
that the prisoner is mentally ill or mentally retarded and is clinically suited
for admission, the corrections mental health program shall provide the prisoner
with a written individual plan of services pursuant to section 712. [FN1] Upon
the prisoner's consent to the individual plan of services, the corrections
mental health program shall admit the prisoner to the
program.
(b) Except as
otherwise provided in subdivision (c), a prisoner who is voluntarily transferred
under this section shall not be admitted to the corrections mental health
program for more than 3 days, excluding Sundays and legal holidays, after the
prisoner gives written notice of his or her intention to terminate the
admission and return to the general population of the state correctional
facility. If the corrections mental health program is advised by a prisoner of
an intention to terminate admission, the program shall promptly provide the
written form required for termination of admission and return the prisoner to
the general population of the state correctional facility.
(c) If written notice
of termination of admission has been given pursuant to subdivision (b) and has
not been withdrawn, and if the director of the corrections mental health
program determines that the prisoner continues to
require mental health services, the director, or a person
designated by the director, within 3 days, excluding Sundays and holidays,
after the receipt by the corrections mental health program of the notice, shall
provide the prisoner and the guardian of the person, if applicable, with a
notice of hearing explaining hearing rights set forth in section 1003c. [FN2]
The prisoner shall not be medicated for 24 hours prior to the hearing. If,
following the hearing, the hearing committee finds that the prisoner does not
require mental health services, the prisoner shall be placed according to
normal procedures of the department of corrections. If the hearing committee
finds that the prisoner continues to require mental health services, the
corrections mental health program shall continue to provide those services.
330.2003c. Hearing for
determination that prisoner is mentally ill or retarded; hearing committee
members; rights of prisoner; evidence; findings and orders; appeal
Sec. 1003c. (1) If a
prisoner refuses treatment or services recommended under section 1003a [FN1] or
if the corrections mental health program determines that a voluntary admittee to the program who wishes to terminate admission
continues to require mental health services, the corrections mental health
program shall appoint a hearing committee to hear the matter. The hearing
committee shall consist of a psychiatrist, a psychologist, and another mental
health professional, whose licensure or registration requirements include a
minimum of a baccalaureate degree from an accredited college or university,
none of whom is, at the time of hearing, involved in the prisoner's treatment
or diagnosis.
(2) A hearing under
this section shall be held not less than 24 hours after the prisoner and the
guardian of the person, if applicable, are provided the
documents required under section 1003a(d) [FN2] or section
1003b(c), [FN3] but not more than 7 business days after the documents have been
provided to the prisoner.
(3) A prisoner has the
following rights with respect to the hearing under this section:
(a) Attendance at the
hearing, and if the prisoner has a guardian of the person, the guardian's
attendance at the hearing.
(b) Presentation of evidence,
including witnesses, who may be family members, and cross-examination of
witnesses, unless the hearing committee finds that the presentation,
confrontation, or cross-examination would present a serious threat to the order
and security of the facility or the safety of the prisoner or others.
(c) Assistance of 1 of
the following persons designated by the director of the corrections mental
health program:
(i)
A recipient rights advisor from the office of recipient rights.
(ii) A mental
health professional who is not involved in the prisoner's treatment or
diagnosis and whose licensure or registration requirements include a minimum of
a baccalaureate degree from an accredited college or university.
(4) The hearing
committee appointed under subsection (1) shall consider the report of the
mental health professional who has alleged that the prisoner is mentally ill or
mentally retarded, the certificate described in section 1003a(1)(b), [FN4]
proof of service of the notice of hearing, proof of nonmedication
for 24 hours prior to the hearing, and any other admissible evidence presented
at the hearing. To be admissible, evidence shall be relevant, nonrepetitious, and of a type relied upon by a person in
the conduct of everyday affairs.
(5) The hearing
committee appointed under subsection (1) shall prepare an official record of
the hearing including all evidence described in subsection (4). The hearing
shall be recorded, but need not be transcribed unless requested by a party. A
party who requests transcription shall pay for the transcription of the portion
requested.
(6) After a hearing
under this section, the hearing committee shall decide by a majority vote that
includes an affirmative vote by the psychiatrist whether the prisoner is
mentally ill or mentally retarded and whether the proposed mental health
services are suitable to the prisoner's condition. If the hearing committee
finds that the prisoner is mentally ill or mentally retarded but that the
proposed services are not suitable to the prisoner's condition, the hearing
committee shall order services available within the corrections mental health
program that are suitable to the prisoner's condition.
(7) Upon reaching a
decision, the hearing committee shall prepare a report and
order expressing the findings of the hearing committee and the
basis for those findings. Each member shall indicate his or her agreement or
disagreement with the hearing committee findings. Within 24 hours after the
hearing, the hearing committee shall provide a copy of the hearing committee
report and order to the prisoner.
(8) A prisoner may
appeal the decision of the hearing committee under this section to the director
of the corrections mental health program if the appeal is filed within 48 hours
of the prisoner's receipt of the hearing committee's report and order under
subsection (7). The director of the corrections mental health program shall
render a decision within 2 business days after receipt of the appeal.
(9) A prisoner may
appeal the decision of the director of the corrections mental health program
under subsection (8) pursuant to section 631 of the revised judicature act of
1961, Act No. 236 of the Public Acts of 1961, being section 600.631 of the
Michigan Compiled Laws,
except that no oral argument shall be permitted. If the director of the
corrections mental health program
upholds the hearing committee's findings of mental illness or
mental retardation and the hearing committee's proposed services, the
prisoner's treatment shall not be stayed pending the appeal.
330.2004. Right to good
time credits and statutory reductions of sentence; disciplinary sanctions;
sentence expiration date
Sec. 1004. (1) A
prisoner shall continue to be credited with those good time credits and other
statutory reductions of his or her penal sentence to which he or she is
entitled while in the corrections mental health program, subject to the terms
and conditions that are applicable in a state correctional facility. The
prisoner shall continue to be subject to all disciplinary sanctions that are
not attributable to the prisoner's mental illness or mental retardation.
(2) At the time a
prisoner is admitted to the corrections mental health program, the department
of corrections shall notify the director of the corrections mental health
program of the date on which the sentence of the prisoner is to expire and of
any reductions of the sentence recorded to date. The corrections mental health
program shall enter the sentence expiration date in the record it maintains for
the prisoner.
330.2004a. Rights and
privileges of prisoners receiving services; confidentiality of medical records;
disclosure
Sec. 1004a. (1) In
addition to the rights, benefits, and privileges guaranteed to prisoners by
other provisions of law, the state constitution of 1963, and the constitution
of the United States, a prisoner receiving services from the corrections mental
health program has the rights enumerated in this section. The rights enumerated
in this section do not replace or limit any other rights, benefits, or
privileges of a prisoner.
(2) The rights
enumerated in this section pertain to the manner in which mental health
services are provided to the prisoner. This section does not affect the
regulations and policies of the department of corrections relating to the
operation of a state correctional facility. In an instance in which a right
enumerated in this section conflicts with a regulation or policy of the
department of corrections affecting the security of a state correctional facility
or the protection of prisoners, employees, or the public, the
department of corrections regulation or policy shall control.
(3) A prisoner is
entitled to receive mental health services suitable to his or her condition in
a manner that protects and promotes the basic human dignity of the prisoner.
(4) Subject to
subsection (2), a prisoner receiving services from the corrections mental
health program is entitled to those rights enumerated in sections 706, 710,
712, 714, 716, 722, 740, 742, 744, and 746. [FN1]
(5) Information in the
medical record of a prisoner receiving services from the corrections mental
health program and other information acquired in the course of the prisoner's
treatment in the program is confidential and shall not be open to public
inspection. The corrections mental health program is the holder of the record
and may disclose the information only in the circumstances and under the
conditions set forth in this subsection. If information made confidential by
this subsection is disclosed, the identity of the individual to
whom it pertains shall be protected and shall not be disclosed
unless it is germane to the authorized purpose for which disclosure was sought;
and, if practicable, other information shall not be disclosed unless it is
germane to the authorized purpose for which disclosure was sought. A person
receiving information made confidential by this subsection shall disclose the
information to others only to the extent consistent with the authorized purpose
for which the information was obtained. With the exception of records, data,
and knowledge generated by individuals or committees performing a peer review
function, which is not subject to disclosure, information pertaining to a
prisoner receiving mental health services from the corrections mental health
program may be disclosed under 1 or more of the following circumstances:
(a) Pursuant to orders
or subpoenas of a court of record, or subpoenas of the legislature, unless the
information is made privileged by law.
(b) To an attorney for
the prisoner, with the prisoner's consent.
(c) If necessary to
comply with another provision of law.
(d) To the department
of corrections if the information is necessary to protect the safety of the
prisoner, other prisoners, or the public, or to protect the prisoner's
interactions with others in the state correctional facility.
(e) To the department
of mental health if the information is necessary for the department to
discharge a responsibility placed upon it by law.
(f) To the office of
the auditor general if the information is necessary for that office to
discharge its constitutional responsibility.
(g) As necessary to
enable a prisoner or the prisoner's surviving spouse or other related person to
apply for or receive benefits.
(h) As necessary for
the purpose of outside research, evaluation, accreditation, or statistical
compilation, if the prisoner can be identified from the disclosure only if that
identification is essential in order to achieve the purpose for which the
information is sought or if preventing that identification would clearly be
impractical, but in no event if the prisoner is likely to be harmed by the
identification.
(i)
To providers of mental health or other health services or a public agency, when
there is a compelling need for disclosure based upon a substantial probability
of harm to the prisoner or to other persons.
(j) To a
representative of the protection and advocacy system designated by the governor
in section 931 [FN2] if both of the following apply:
(i)
A complaint regarding the provision of mental health services by the
corrections mental health program has been received by the protection and
advocacy system from or on behalf of the prisoner.
(ii) The
prisoner does not have a legal guardian, or the state or the designee of the
state is the legal guardian of the prisoner.
330.2004b. Notice of
rights to prisoner; opportunity to consult with designated persons
Sec. 1004b. (1) Not
later than 7 days after a prisoner is admitted to the corrections mental health
program, the corrections mental health program shall provide the prisoner with
a notice of the rights guaranteed under section 1004a. [FN1] The program shall
also provide the prisoner with an opportunity to consult with 1 of the following
persons designated by the director of the corrections mental health program:
(a) A recipient rights
advisor from the office of recipient rights.
(b) A field
investigator from the office of the legislative corrections ombudsman.
(c) A representative
of the protection and advocacy agency designated by the governor pursuant to
section 931. [FN2]
(2) The corrections
mental health program shall place in the record of each prisoner admitted to
the program a document signed by the prisoner stating that the prisoner
received the notice required under subsection (1) and was offered an
opportunity to consult with a person described in subsection (1)(a) to (c).
330.2005d. Initial
order for treatment; report of a determination for continued care; hearing;
orders for continued care; mandatory certificate from psychiatrist or
psychologist
Sec. 1005d. (1) An
initial order for treatment under section 1003c [FN1] shall be for a period not
to exceed 90 days.
(2) If, before the
expiration of the initial 90-day order, the treating psychiatrist or
psychologist believes that a prisoner continues to be mentally ill or mentally
retarded and requires mental health services, the treating psychiatrist or
psychologist, not less than 14 days before the expiration of the order, shall
file with the director of the corrections mental health program or the
director's designee a report of the determination that the prisoner continues
to require those services. Upon receipt of the report under this subsection and
proof of notice to the prisoner of an opportunity for a hearing, and following
a hearing, if requested by the prisoner, a hearing committee appointed pursuant
to section 1003c may authorize continued care in
the corrections mental health program for an additional period not
to exceed 90 days.
(3) If, before the
expiration of the second 90-day order, the treating psychiatrist or
psychologist believes that the condition of a prisoner is such that the
prisoner continues to be mentally ill or mentally retarded and requires mental
health services, the treating psychiatrist or psychologist, not less than 14
days before the expiration of the order, shall file with the director of the
corrections mental health program or the director's designee a report of the determination
that the prisoner continues to require those services. Upon receipt of the
report under this subsection and proof of notice to the prisoner of an
opportunity for a hearing, and following a hearing, if requested by the
prisoner, the hearing committee may authorize continued care in the corrections
mental health program for an additional period not to exceed 180 days. Upon
completion of the order for continuing admission to the corrections mental
health program, if the treating psychiatrist or psychologist believes that the
prisoner continues to be mentally ill or mentally retarded and requires mental
health services, the treating psychiatrist or psychologist shall request an
initial order of admission
pursuant to section 1003c.
(4) A report of a determination
under subsection (2) or (3) shall be accompanied by a certificate executed by
the psychiatrist or psychologist and shall contain a statement setting forth
all of the following:
(a) The reasons for
the treating psychiatrist's or psychologist's determination that the prisoner
continues to be mentally ill or mentally retarded and requires mental health
services.
(b) A statement
describing the treatment program provided to the prisoner.
(c) The results of the
course of treatment.
(d) A clinical
estimate as to the time further treatment will be required.
(5) If at any hearing
held under this section the hearing committee appointed under section 1003c
finds that the prisoner is not mentally ill or mentally retarded, the hearing
committee shall enter a finding to that effect and the prisoner shall be placed
according to normal procedures of the department of corrections.
330.2005f. Transfers to
other mental health facilities; administrative hearing; commingling; rights and
privileges
Sec. 1005f. (1) A
person may be transferred to the center for forensic psychiatry program under
this chapter and may be transferred between state mental health facilities upon
authorization by the director of the center for forensic psychiatry program.
The person is entitled to an administrative hearing pursuant to rules of the
department of mental health regarding the need and appropriateness of a
transfer to another state mental health facility upon receipt by the director
of the center for forensic psychiatry program of the person's objection to the
transfer. If an emergency transfer is required, and if objection is made to the
transfer, the hearing will be held at the receiving facility.
(2) A person
transferred to another state mental health facility under this section shall
not be commingled with other recipients of mental health services except in
cases in which it is determined by the director of the center for
forensic psychiatry program, after consultation with the
department of corrections, and pursuant to rules promulgated by the department
of mental health, that the person and the other recipients of mental health
services exhibit the same propensity for dangerous behavior and require similar
treatment plans and modalities.
(3) A person transferred
under this section is entitled to all the rights and privileges afforded to
other mental health recipients pursuant to chapter 7, [FN1] except those rights
and privileges specifically excluded or modified by law.
330.2006. Discharge of
prisoners from corrections mental health program; notification and required
reports; petition for continued treatment of prisoners paroled or discharged
from prison
Sec. 1006. (1) A
prisoner admitted to the corrections mental health program pursuant to section
1003a [FN1] or section 1003b [FN2] shall be discharged from the program when 1
or more of the following occur:
(a) The prisoner
ceases to require mental health services.
(b) The prisoner is
paroled or discharged from prison.
(2) If a prisoner is
to be discharged from the corrections mental health program before the
expiration of the prisoner's criminal sentence, the director of the corrections
mental health program shall first notify the department of
corrections of the pending discharge, and shall transmit a full
report on the condition of the prisoner to the department of corrections.
(3) If the prisoner is
paroled or discharged from prison, and the corrections mental health program
considers the prisoner to be a person requiring treatment, as defined in
section 401, [FN3] or a person who meets the criteria for judicial admission,
as prescribed in section 515, [FN4] the director of the corrections mental
health program at least 14 days before the parole date or the date of discharge
shall file a petition pursuant to section 434 [FN5] or section 516 [FN6] asserting that the prisoner is a person requiring
treatment or that the prisoner meets the criteria for judicial admission. The
petition shall be filed with the probate court of the prisoner's county of
residence.
(4) The department of
mental health is responsible for assuring that needed
aftercare reintegration and community-based mental health services
are offered to mentally ill and mentally retarded persons who are leaving
prison, upon referral by the department of corrections. Upon request from the
department of corrections, community-based mental health services shall be
provided by the department of mental health throughout the parole period.
330.2006a. Report to
legislature; contents; recommendations for changes in mental health programs
for prisoners
Sec. 1006a. (1) Not
later than April 1, 1995, the department of corrections and the department of
mental health shall submit a report to the legislature, based on a joint
evaluation, that includes, but is not limited to, all of the following with
respect to the 18-month period preceding the report:
(a) A description of
the provision of mental health services to prisoners.
(b) The total number
of prisoners served.
(c) The number of
hearings held pursuant to section 1003c [FN1] and the disposition of each
hearing.
(d) The number of
developmentally disabled prisoners in the corrections system and a description
of the services those prisoners received.
(e) The
characteristics of the prisoners served and a description of the services they
received, including, but not limited to, the length of stay in the corrections
mental health program and the type of treatment received.
(2) The report
required under subsection (1) shall include recommendations for appropriate
changes in mental health programs for prisoners.
330.2020. Competency,
presumption; incompetency, determination; medication
Sec. 1020. (1) A
defendant to a criminal charge shall be presumed competent to stand trial. He
shall be determined incompetent to stand trial only if he is incapable because
of his mental condition of understanding the nature and object of the
proceedings against him or of assisting in his defense in a rational manner.
The court shall determine the capacity of a defendant to assist in his defense
by his ability to perform the tasks reasonably necessary for him to perform in
the preparation of his defense and during his trial.
(2) A defendant shall
not be determined incompetent to stand trial because psychotropic drugs or
other medication have been or are being administered under proper medical
direction, and even though without such medication the defendant might be
incompetent to stand trial. However, when the defendant is receiving such
medication, the court may, prior to making its determination on the issue of
incompetence to stand trial, require the filing of a statement by the treating
physician that such medication will not adversely affect the
defendant's understanding of the proceedings or his ability to
assist in his defense.
330.2022. Incompetency of defendant, stay, motions, preservation of
evidence
Sec. 1022. (1) A
defendant who is determined incompetent to stand trial shall not be proceeded
against while he is incompetent.
(2) Any pretrial
motion may be made by either the defense or prosecution while a defendant is
incompetent to stand trial, and the issues presented by the motion shall be
heard and decided if the presence of the defendant is not essential for a fair
hearing and decision on the motion.
(3) When it appears
that evidence essential to the case the defense or prosecution plans to present
might not be available at the time of trial, the court shall allow such
evidence to be taken and preserved. Evidence so taken shall be admissible at
the trial only if it is not otherwise available. Procedures for the taking and
preserving of evidence under this subsection, and the conditions under which
such evidence shall be admissible at trial, shall be
provided by court rule.
330.2024. Raising issue
of incompetence
Sec. 1024. The issue
of incompetence to stand trial may be raised by the defense, court, or
prosecution. The time and form of the procedure for raising the issue shall be
provided by court rule.
330.2026. Examination
as to competency
Sec. 1026. (1) Upon a
showing that the defendant may be incompetent to stand trial, the court shall
order the defendant to undergo an examination by personnel of either the center
for forensic psychiatry or other facility officially certified by the
department of mental health to perform examinations relating to the issue of
incompetence to stand trial. The defendant shall make himself available for the
examination at the places and times established by the center or other
certified facility. If the defendant, after being notified, fails to make
himself available for the examination, the court may order his commitment to
the center or other facility without a hearing.
(2) When the defendant
is to be held in a jail or similar place of detention pending trial, the center
or other facility may perform the examination in the jail or may notify the
sheriff to transport the defendant to the center or other facility for the
examination, and the sheriff shall return the defendant to the jail upon
completion of the examination.
(3) Except as provided
in subsection (1), when the defendant is not to be held in a jail or similar
place of detention pending trial, the court shall commit him to the center or
other facility only when the commitment is necessary for the performance of the
examination.
(4) The defendant
shall be released by the center or other facility upon completion of the
examination.
330.2028. Examination
of defendant; consultation with counsel; report; opinions
Sec. 1028. (1) When
the defendant is ordered to undergo an examination pursuant to section 1026,
[FN1] the center or other facility shall, for the purpose of gathering
psychiatric and other information pertinent to the issue of the incompetence of
the defendant to stand trial, examine the defendant and consult with defense
counsel, and may consult with the prosecutor or other persons. Defense counsel
shall make himself available for consultation with the center or other
facility. The examination shall be performed, defense counsel consulted, and a
written report submitted to the court, prosecuting attorney, and defense
counsel within 60 days of the date of the order.
(a) The clinical
findings of the center or other facility.
(b) The facts, in
reasonable detail, upon which the findings are based, and upon request of the
court, defense, or prosecution additional facts germane to the findings.
(c) The opinion of the
center or other facility on the issue of the incompetence of the defendant to
stand trial.
(d) If the opinion is
that the defendant is incompetent to stand trial, the opinion of the center or
other facility on the likelihood of the defendant attaining competence to stand
trial, if provided a course of treatment, within the time limit established by
section 1034. [FN2]
(3) The opinion
concerning competency to stand trial derived from the examination may not be
admitted as evidence for any purpose in the pending criminal proceedings,
except on the issues to be determined in the hearings
required or permitted by sections 1030 and 1040. [FN3] The
foregoing bar of testimony shall not be construed to prohibit the examining
qualified clinician from presenting at other stages in the criminal proceedings
opinions concerning criminal responsibility, disposition, or other issues if
they were originally requested by the court and are available. Information
gathered in the course of a prior examination that is of historical value to
the examining qualified clinician may be utilized in the formulation of an
opinion in any subsequent court ordered evaluation.
330.2030. Appearance;
hearing; evidence; medication; determination
Sec. 1030. (1) Upon
receipt of the written report, the court shall cause the defendant to appear in
court and shall hold a hearing within 5 days or upon the conclusion of the
case, proceeding, or other matter then before it, whichever is sooner, unless
the defense or prosecution for good cause requests a delay for a reasonable
time.
(2) On the basis of
the evidence admitted at the hearing, the court shall determine the issue of
the incompetence of the defendant to stand trial. If the defendant is
determined incompetent to stand trial, the court shall also determine whether
there is a substantial probability that the defendant, if provided a course of
treatment, will attain competence to stand trial within the time limit
established by section 1034. [FN1]
(3) The written report
shall be admissible as competent evidence in the
hearing, unless the defense or prosecution objects, but not for
any other purpose in the pending criminal proceeding. The defense, prosecution,
and the court on its own motion may present additional evidence relevant to the
issues to be determined at the hearing.
(4) If the defendant
is receiving medication and is not determined incompetent to stand trial, the
court may, in order to maintain the competence of the defendant to stand trial,
make such orders as it deems appropriate for the continued administration of
such medication pending and during trial.
330.2031. Petition for
judicial admission of incompetent defendant
Sec. 1031. If the
defendant is determined incompetent to stand trial, and if the court determines
that there is not a substantial probability that, if provided a course of
treatment, he will attain competence to stand trial within the time limit
established by section 1034, [FN1] the court may direct a prosecuting attorney
to file a petition asserting that the defendant is a person requiring treatment
as defined by section 401 [FN2] or meets the criteria for judicial admission as
defined by section 515 [FN3] with the probate court of the defendant's county
of residence.
330.2032. Treatment to
render defendant competent
Sec. 1032. (1) If the
defendant is determined incompetent to stand trial, and if the court determines
that there is a substantial probability that, if provided a course of
treatment, he will attain competence to stand trial within the time limit
established by section 1034, [FN1] the court shall order him to undergo
treatment to render him competent to stand trial.
(2) The court shall
appoint a medical supervisor of the course of treatment. The supervisor may be
any person or agency willing to supervise the course of treatment, or the
department of mental health.
(3) The court may
commit the defendant to the custody of the department of mental health, or to
the custody of any other inpatient mental health facility if it agrees, only if
commitment is necessary for the effective administration of the course of
treatment. If the defendant, absent commitment to the
department of mental health or other inpatient facility, would
otherwise be held in a jail or similar place of detention pending trial, the
court may enter an order restricting the defendant in his movements to the
buildings and grounds of the facility at which he is to be treated.
330.2034. Time
limitation on treatment
Sec. 1034. (1) No
order or combination of orders issued under section 1032 or 1040, [FN1] or
both, shall have force and effect for a total period in excess of 15 months or
1/3 of the maximum sentence the defendant could receive if convicted of the
charges against him, whichever is lesser; nor after the charges against the
defendant are dismissed.
(2) The court shall
provide for notification of defense counsel, the prosecution, and the medical
supervisor of treatment whenever the charges against the defendant are
dismissed and whenever an order whose stated time period has not elapsed is
voided by the court.
(3) If the defendant
is to be discharged or released because of the expiration of an order or orders
under section 1032 or 1040, the supervisor of treatment prior to the discharge
or release may file a petition asserting that the
defendant is a person requiring treatment as defined by section
401 [FN2] or meets the criteria for judicial admission as defined by section
515 [FN3] with the probate court of the defendant's county of residence.
330.2036. Right to
liberty pending trial
Sec. 1036. The right
of the defendant to be at liberty pending trial, on bail or otherwise, shall
not be impaired because the issue of incompetence to stand trial has been
raised, because the defendant has been determined incompetent to stand trial,
or because the defendant has been ordered to undergo treatment to render him
competent to stand trial, except to the extent authorized by section 1026 [FN1]
for the purpose of an examination or by section 1032 [FN2] for the purpose of
administering a course of treatment.
330.2038. Treatment reports
Sec. 1038. (1) The
medical supervisor of treatment shall transmit a written report to the court,
prosecuting attorney, defense counsel, and the center for forensic psychiatry:
(a) At least once
every 90 days from the date of an order issued pursuant to section 1032. [FN1]
(b) Whenever he is of
the opinion that the defendant is no longer incompetent to stand trial.
(c) Whenever he is of
the opinion that there is not a substantial probability that the defendant,
with treatment, will attain competence to stand trial within the time limit
established by section 1034. [FN2]
(2) The reports shall
be admissible pursuant to section 1030(3) [FN3] and shall contain:
(a) The clinical
findings of the supervisor of treatment.
(b) The facts, in
reasonable detail, upon which the findings are based, and upon request of the
court, defense, or prosecution additional facts germane to the findings.
(c) The opinion of the
supervisor of treatment on the issue of the incompetence of the defendant to
stand trial.
(d) If the opinion is
that the defendant is incompetent to stand trial, the opinion of the supervisor
of treatment on whether the defendant has made
progress toward attaining competence to stand trial during the
course of treatment.
330.2040. Redetermination of incompetency
Sec. 1040. (1) The
court shall forthwith hear and redetermine the issue
of the incompetence of the defendant to stand trial and, if the defendant is redetermined incompetent to stand trial, shall hear and
determine whether the defendant has made progress toward attaining competence
to stand trial during his course of treatment, whenever the court receives a
report from the supervisor of treatment, unless the defense waives the hearing,
or whenever deemed appropriate by the court.
(2) Section 1030 [FN1]
shall govern hearings held pursuant to this section.
(3) If the defendant
is not redetermined incompetent to stand trial at a
hearing held pursuant to this section, trial shall commence as soon as
practicable. If the defendant is redetermined
incompetent to stand trial, and if the court determines that the defendant has
made progress toward attaining
competence to stand trial, the court may modify or continue any
orders it previously issued under section 1032. [FN2]
330.2042. Credit for
time spent in custody
Sec. 1042. Time spent
in custody because of orders issued pursuant to sections 1026, 1032, and 1040
[FN1] shall be credited against any sentence imposed on the defendant in the
pending criminal case or in any other case arising from the same transaction.
330.2044. Dismissal of
charges, incompetent defendant; subsequent filing of charges
Sec. 1044. (1) The
charges against a defendant determined incompetent to stand trial shall be
dismissed:
(a) When the
prosecutor notifies the court of his intention not to prosecute the case; or
(b) Fifteen months
after the date on which the defendant was originally determined incompetent to
stand trial.
(2) When charges are
dismissed pursuant to subsection (1), the same charges, or other charges
arising from the transaction which gave rise to the dismissed charges, shall
not subsequently be filed against the defendant, except as
provided in this section.
(3) If the charges
were dismissed pursuant to subsection (1)(b) and if the crime charged was
punishable by a sentence of life imprisonment, the prosecutor may at any time
petition the court for permission to again file charges. In the case of other
charges dismissed pursuant to subsection (1)(b), the prosecutor may, within that
period of time after the charges were dismissed equal to 1/3 of the maximum
sentence that the defendant could receive on the charges, petition the court
for permission to again file charges.
(4) The court shall
grant permission to again file charges if after a hearing it determines that
the defendant is competent to stand trial. Prior to the hearing, the court may
order the defendant to be examined by personnel of the center for forensic
psychiatry or other qualified person as an outpatient, but may not commit the
defendant to the center or any other facility for the examination.
330.2050. Acquittal by
reason of insanity; commitment; examination; report; petition; hearing;
disposition
Sec. 1050. (1) The
court shall immediately commit any person who is acquitted of a criminal charge
by reason of insanity to the custody of the center for forensic psychiatry, for
a period not to exceed 60 days. The court shall forward to the center a full
report, in the form of a settled record, of the facts concerning the crime
which the patient was found to have committed but of which he was acquitted by
reason of insanity. The center shall thoroughly examine and evaluate the
present mental condition of the person in order to reach an opinion on whether
the person meets the criteria of a person requiring treatment or for judicial
admission set forth in section 401 or 515. [FN1]
(2) Within the 60-day
period the center shall file a report with the court, prosecuting attorney, and
defense counsel. The report shall contain a summary of the crime which the
patient committed but of which he was acquitted by reason of insanity and an
opinion as to whether the person meets the criteria
of a person requiring treatment or for judicial admission as
defined by section 401 or 515, and the facts upon which the opinion is based.
If the opinion stated is that the person is a person requiring treatment, the
report shall be accompanied by certificates from 2 physicians, at least 1 of
whom shall be a psychiatrist, which conform to the requirements of section
400(j). [FN2]
(3) After receipt of
the report, the court may direct the prosecuting attorney to file a petition
pursuant to section 434 or 516 [FN3] for an order of
hospitalization or an order of admission to a facility with the probate court
of the person's county of residence or of the county in which the criminal
trial was held. Any certificates that accompanied the report of the center may
be filed with the petition, and shall be sufficient to cause a hearing to be
held pursuant to section 451 [FN4] even if they were not
executed within 72 hours of the filing of the petition. The report from the
court containing the facts concerning the crime for which he was acquitted by
reason of insanity shall be admissible in the hearings.
(4) If the report
states the opinion that the person meets the criteria of a
person requiring treatment or for judicial admission, and if a
petition is to be filed pursuant to subsection (3), the center may retain the
person pending a hearing on the petition. If a petition is not to be filed, the
prosecutor shall notify the center in writing. The center, upon receipt of the
notification, shall cause the person to be discharged.
(5) The release
provisions of sections 476 to 479 [FN5] of this act shall
apply to a person found to have committed a crime by a court or jury, but who
is acquitted by reason of insanity, except that a person shall not be
discharged or placed on leave without first being evaluated and recommended for
discharge or leave by the department's program for forensic psychiatry, and
authorized leave or absence from the hospital may be extended for a period of 5
years.
Constitution of the State of Michigan
Chapter 330 Mental Health Code
_ Department of Mental
Health
_ The Hospital act for
Mentally Disabled Persons
_ Interstate compact on
Mental Health
_ Specific hospitals
listed