Antipsychotics
are being widely prescribed to children with behaviour and mood
problems, with a significant proportion going to children under nine,
new research shows.
Ninety-four per cent of 176 child
psychiatrists in Canada surveyed are prescribing powerful drugs known
as atypical antipsychotics for a variety of disorders and symptoms,
including anxiety, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder and "poor
frustration tolerance."
While most prescriptions were for
children 13 and older, a "surprising" number were for the very young:
12% of all prescriptions were for children aged eight or under,
including three-year-olds.
None of the drugs has been officially
approved for use in children. Risperidone (brand name Respirdal) was
the most commonly prescribed atypical antipsychotic to children,
followed by olanzapine (Zyprexa) and quetiapine (Seroquel).
All are in a different class from Ritalin, a stimulant used to treat attention deficit disorder in children.
Originally
developed to treat schizophrenia and mania, so-called ATAs are now
increasingly being used to treat non-psychotic disorders in adults,
children and teens.
"These medications are currently being used
off-label without clear guidelines for indications, dosing and
monitoring," researchers report in the most recent issue of the
Canadian Journal of Psychiatry.
"There is an urgent need for more data regarding safety and monitoring of these medications in children."
In
the U.S., the number of visits to a doctor that ended with a patient
under 20 being prescribed an anti-psychotic soared six-fold between
1993 and 2002.
The new Canadian survey can't answer just how
many children or teens in Canada are on antipsychotics. But it shows
prescribing by child psychiatrists and pediatricians who specialize in
developmental problems is "ubiquitous."
"The trouble with a study
like this is, it doesn't tell us whether that's a good thing or a bad
thing. We just know it's happening," says lead author Dr. Tamison Doey,
head of the division of child and adolescent psychiatry for the city of
Windsor and an adjunct professor at the University of Western Ontario.
"Intuitively
we all say, Geez, these are young kids to be on medicine. But kids that
age are put on drugs for asthma, and they're given antibiotics and
different sorts of medication. I think we all get a bit concerned if
it's something that affects the brain."
As doctors become more confident with ATAs, the drugs are filling an important niche, Dr. Doey says.
"We
have data to show they are helpful. The concern is we also have data
showing that when you stop the medication, many times the problems come
back. That means you're maybe looking at having to take these drugs for
the long term. Then you start to worry, these are kids, what will
happen down the road?'"
Most of the specialists surveyed monitored their patients. But the types and frequency of tests performed vary widely.
"The
concern is, will other doctors start to use these medicines and how can
we guide them to do it appropriately," Dr. Doey says.
Atypical
anti-psychotics are considered a significant improvement over older
antipsychotics that were used in both adults and children. For one
thing, they don't cause the same neurological side effects, such as
uncontrolled jerking and twisting.
But they can cause
substantial weight gain. Johns Hopkins researchers have warned the
drugs might trigger insulin resistance in children, increasing the risk
of developing Type 2 diabetes and heart disease when they're older.
The
drugs work by blocking dopamine, a brain chemical involved in
aggression and impulsivity. Doey says they can make the difference
between a having a child in school or not, "or a child having friends
or having terrible outbursts every time something doesn't go their way."
They are being used to treat depression, impulsivity and children who frustrate easily.
"That
doesn't mean they just get a bit upset. The kids we see will have major
aggressive or disruptive episodes for even the slightest reasons," Dr.
Doey says. "So if they can't do something in school or someone tells
them to turn off the television or you can't run in the corridor, you
name it, they proceed to become very angry and aggressive and out of
control."
Her team plans to follow children prescribed atypical
antipsychotics over a year to look at the effects of the drugs over the
longer term.
skirkey@canwest.com